Relationship Signals That Show You’re Losing Your Vanilla


Transitioning from a vanilla relationship to exploring a more adventurous or nontraditional lifestyle is an exciting journey, but it’s not always one that begins with a clear starting point. Often, couples start noticing subtle (or not-so-subtle) signs that their relationship is evolving beyond traditional boundaries.
So, how do you know you’re “losing your vanilla?” Here are some relationship signals that may indicate you’re ready to embrace something new:
1. You’re Having Open Conversations About Fantasies
One of the biggest signals is a change in communication. If you and your partner are having honest, judgment-free conversations about fantasies, things like exploring with other couples, soft swapping, or trying new kinks. Even in moments of passion, these fantasies are a clear sign that your relationship is evolving.
Why it matters: These conversations show trust and a desire to explore together, which are key components of stepping beyond vanilla.
2. You’re Both Watching or Reading Porn Together
Couples who move away from vanilla often start by exploring adult content together. If you find yourselves browsing specific genres or discussing what you like and dislike, it’s a signal that your curiosity is growing.
Tip: Use this as an opportunity to understand each other’s preferences and boundaries, creating a foundation for future exploration.
3. You’ve Started Talking About Swinging or the Lifestyle
Has the idea of visiting a lifestyle resort, club, or party come up in casual conversation? Maybe one of you joked about going to a swinger’s event, and instead of shutting it down quickly as a joke, you both got a little curious.
Why it matters: Even lighthearted conversations about the lifestyle are often a gateway to more serious discussions about your desires and boundaries.
4. You’re Both Exploring Sexy Communities Online
If you’ve created accounts on platforms like SDC, Kasidie, or even explored social forums like Reddit’s swinging or polyamory groups, you’re dipping your toes into the lifestyle world. This is often one of the first steps couples take as they begin exploring.
Sign to look for: You find yourselves more excited about these spaces than other traditional hobbies or online groups.
5. You’re Attending Parties or Events “Just to See”
Maybe you’ve gone to a meet and greet, a lifestyle friendly resort, or even a themed party, telling yourselves, “We’re just here to observe.” The key is, even without participating, you’re taking steps toward embracing this new world.
Why it matters: Curiosity often leads to comfort, which then leads to participation.
6. You’re Discussing Boundaries and Comfort Zones
Conversations about boundaries and comfort zones signal a readiness to move beyond vanilla. These discussions often include:
• What you’d be okay trying.
• What feels off limits.
• How to communicate if something feels uncomfortable.
Why it matters: The more openly you discuss boundaries, the more trust you’re building, which is very important in non vanilla relationships.
7. You’re Experimenting with Kink or Roleplay
Perhaps you’ve started incorporating new elements into your intimacy, like light bondage, roleplay, or trying out toys together. This willingness to explore new dynamics shows you’re both eager to break free from traditional routines.
Tip: Start slow and communicate throughout the process to ensure you’re both enjoying the experience.
8. You Feel More Connected Than Ever
A hallmark signal of losing your vanilla is feeling a deeper bond with your partner. These new explorations often bring couples closer together because they require communication, trust, and mutual respect beyond what is considered “normal”.
Sign to watch for: You’re both more open, honest, and excited about your relationship than ever before.
9. You’re Open to Meeting Like Minded People
You might find yourself drawn to events, communities, or friendships with others who share a more adventurous approach to relationships. If you’re actively seeking out these connections, it’s a strong signal that you’re ready to leave vanilla behind.
10. You’re Talking About “Rules” Instead of Saying “No”
Instead of dismissing an idea outright, you’re discussing what it would take to make it work. For example, one of you suggests soft swapping, and the other responds with, “Maybe, but only if…” rather than “Absolutely not.”
Why it matters: This shows a change in mindset from “hell nah” to “hmmm.”
Embracing the Change
Losing your vanilla isn’t a bad thing; it means your relationship is reaching a new level in new and exciting ways. The key to this fun transition is communication, trust, and mutual exploration. If you’re seeing these signals in your relationship, it might be time to sit down and discuss what’s next for your journey together.
Remember, there’s no “right” way to explore non-traditional relationships — only the way that works for you and your partner. Whether you’re a newbie or jumping into the lifestyle, the most important thing is to embrace the journey.
So, what’s your next step? Your non-vanilla adventure awaits!